Top Boy[]
The Weird Sisters support Sabrina's run for Top Boy
Dorcas, Agatha, and Prudence gather with the rest of the student body for the election of Top Boy. One warlock chosen to serve as a liaison between students and faculty. Nick is nominated. Sabrina offers to contest the election on the grounds that she had signed the Book of the Beast. She calls for all students regardless of their gender to have a voice. Nick nominates Sabrina and is seconded by Prudence. As part of the Top Boy selection, Father Blackwood announces that the candidates have to take part in three challenges at the Desecrated Church: the Inquisition, the Boil and Bubble, and the Conjuring. This will be followed by a vote.
The Weird Sisters at the Conjuring test
As the the Inquisition commences at the Desecrated Church, the Weird Sisters telepathically wire the answer to Sabrina from the Academy's library, resulting in a victory for Sabrina. The Weird Sisters also attend the Conjuring test, during which time Sabrina and Nick accuse Father Blackwood or a member of the coven of sending high demons to attack her. And as proof, they summon the Plague Kings to get answers.[1]
The Passion of Lucifer Morningstar[]
Zelda, Dorcas, and Nick rehearse
At the Desecrated Church, Dorcas rehearses with Nick and Zelda for the play, The Passion of Lucifer Morningstar. Watching the rehearsal, Sabrina whispers that Dorcas is a terrible actress, as the Dark Lord appears, telling her that the role should be hers. He suggests that she pulls a pin holding a rope with a sandbag hanging above Dorcas. Sabrina pulls the pin and the sandbag falls on Dorcas. It turns out that it was just an illusion; the pin is still in place. Sabrina starts repeating "I won't do it" out loud, with the others looking at her, asking who she is talking to. She answers that she was talking to no one and they all leave for lunch.
Nick and Dorcas rehearse
Dorcas, Agatha, and Prudence rush over to help to Sabrina after she chocked on a apple while rehearsing with Nick for the play. The following day at the Desecrated Church, Dorcas and Nick continue their rehearsal as Prudence and Agatha watch on. Zelda interrupts and tries to speak, but a frog pops out of her mouth, much to Prudence and Agatha's amusement. She holds the frog and asks the students which one of them did this to her. Prudence tells her that the frog is Sister Shirley Jackson's familiar. It's later revealed that Dorcas came down with chickenpox and Sabrina replaces her in the play.[2]
Lupercalia[]
In celebration of the upcoming Lupercalia, witches' version of Valentine's Day, Dorcas, Agatha, Prudence, Sabrina, Nicholas, and Ambrose attend a party at Dorian's Gray Room.
Dorcas plans to take Nick from Sabrina
Father Blackwood opens the Matching ceremony. Dorcas warns Sabrina that she intends to be paired up with Nick. Two years ago, it was Prudence and the year after that it was Agatha. Dorcas believes it to be her turn. As Top Boy, Ambrose organizes the participants. Ambrose tells the witches to pair up with the closest warlock when the music stops. The witches dance with long fabric around a pole. Sabrina tries to pair up with Nick, but Dorcas pushes her out of the way. However, Nick had bribed his friend Melvin into wearing a glamour, trapping Dorcas with him. Sabrina and Nick are jubilant.
The Courting ceremony
Later that night, Ambrose briefs the couples about the Courting ceremony. He explains that they will go into the woods and disrobe and anoint themselves under the moonlight, absorbing the potency of Goddess Selene. Abstinence is encouraged in anticipation for the powerful release that concludes Lupercalia, but he is not opposed to couples having sex. As Prudence passes out anointment baskets with items inside such oysters and figs, Father Blackwood warns the couples to stay on the path due to the dangerous creatures in the woods. The couples head into the wood.
Dorcas finds Nick
The last night of Lupercalia has arrived. As the girls prepare for the hunt, Agatha tells Prudence about her plans to have sex with Melvin, whom she believes to be a virgin. However, Dorcas reveals that she already had sex with Melvin during the night of the Courting. Prudence tells them to prepare for the hunt. Nick, Melvin, and the other warlocks stand in a group to Ambrose's left, dressed as wolves, while Dorcas, Prudence, Agatha, Sabrina and the remaining witches, dressed in red hoods, stand to his right. As part of the Hunt, the witches chase the warlocks through the woods. The Hunt begins, and Dorcas intercepts Nick to have sex with him.[3]
The Weird Sisters flirt with Nick
The Weird Sisters appear in Sabrina's vision. They flirt with Nick at the Academy, much to Sabrina's discomfort. Prudence asks Sabrina if they are taking part in the Academy's talent show. Nick explains that they hold a talent show each year to blow off some steam. He tells her that he is thinking of being a magician this year and asks if Sabrina would like to be the magician’s assistant. Prudence offers to lend her some fishnet stockings. Nick tells her to shut up, but Prudence responds that she was not the one who killed his familiar Amalia and didn't fulfill Lupercalia tradition by having sex.
Nick asks for Dorcas and Agatha's help
The Weird Sisters attend the talent show hosted at the Desecrated Church. For Nick's first act, he picks Dorcas and Agatha as volunteers. Nick gets Agatha to lie in a box which is then sawed in half. When he opens the box, Agatha, to the horror of everyone, is sawed in half, with her guts spilling out. However, Nick and Dorcas soon reveal this was a trick and Agatha steps out of a large box.
For his third and final act, Nick calls for the bravest lady in the room. Sabrina volunteers for this trick. Nick asks her if she has experienced true weightlessness and tells her to trust him. Nick uses a magic trick to levitate Sabrina into the air. However, he struggles to control his powers due to the Weird Sisters' interference.
Dorcas and Agatha also appears briefly in Zelda's vision with Ambrose. She asks them about the whereabouts of Father Blackwood, but they don't know. [4]
Visions of Bloodshed[]
The Weird Sisters warn Father Blackwood
The Weird Sisters enter Father Blackwood's bedroom as he's shaving. His body covered with ritualistic tattoos. They shared a dream. The timing is alarming given the Anti-Pope's visit and Father Blackwood's marriage to Zelda. The Weird Sisters hold hands and tell him that they saw an altar, a coffin and much bloodshed. They warn him to beware of the Spellmans, claiming they will be the undoing of the Blackwoods. Blackwood dismisses their warning and claims that the Spellmans are at his mercy. He orders them to go to bed and dream no more of blood.
The Weird Sisters meet the Anti-Pope
The entire Academy gathers to welcome the Anti-Pope. As he is guided into the dormitory by Father Blackwood and Zelda, Father Blackwood introduces Nick to the Anti-Pope. When Prudence asks her father if he is going to introduce her and the Weird Sisters, Father Blackwood introduces her as Prudence Night, describing her as one of the "gutter orphans" the Academy fosters, along with Dorcas and Agatha.
That night, Dorcas discovers the Anti-Pope has been murdered. She screams, alarming the Academy. Father Blackwood, Zelda, and Prudence enter Enoch of Antioch's chambers to find that he has been hacked to death. Blackwood strikes down two of the Judas Society stalwarts guarding him. Despite Zelda and Hilda's pleas, he tries to strike down Ambrose, who manages to teleport to safety. He orders the others to find the traitor.[5]
Witch-Hunters In Greendale[]
Dorcas flirts with Ambrose
Ambrose is capture and placed in the Witch's Cell. Dorcas enters with his gruel rations. Ambrose requests something more succulent and rubs his body against Dorcas. Prudence tells Ambrose to get away from her sister, shoving Dorcas to the ground and causing her to drop the tray of gruel. She chides Dorcas for her infatuation with Ambrose, who then tries to flirt with Prudence, but she denounces him as a traitor and tells him that he will rot in this cell until he provides a confession. Ambrose says he has spent 75 years under house arrest and that it will take more to break him. So Prudence allows the Infernal Bailiff to rough Ambrose up.
Dorcas advises Ambrose to plead guilty
The Weird Sisters deny Hilda access to the Academy as she wishes to bring a plump chicken for Ambrose. However, Hilda offers the chicken to them in exchange for allowing her to visit Ambrose. Prudence allows Hilda to spend time with "Ambrose," who in actuality is Agatha in glamour. Prudence then leads "Hilda," who is really Dorcas, into Ambrose's cell in hopes of getting him to confess to killing the Anti-Pope. However, both Ambrose and Hilda see past their tricks.
The Weird Sisters enlist in the students' help
The Weird Sisters have gathered the students in the lobby. With their help, Dorcas, Agatha, and Prudence tell the students that tonight they are collecting their energies to enact a spell of compulsion. She enlists their help on forcing Ambrose to confess to the murder of the Anti-Pope. The witches and warlocks begin chanting in unison. Ambrose escapes his cell and warns the Academy that the witch-hunters have come. Prudence orders the other witches and warlocks to hide while she and the Weird Sisters face the intruders. Jerathmiel and Mehitable enter the lobby and demand that the witches and warlocks come out of hiding.
The Weird Sisters are attacked
Dorcas, Agatha, and Prudence emerge from hiding and use magic to force the two witch-hunters to their knees. She tells Jerathmiel that the pain in his head is his brain atomizing into sand and Mehitable that the pain in her chest is her lungs hardening. The Weird Sisters tell the witch-hunters that they are no ordinary witches but they are the daughters of the Church of Night, the "Three-In-One." However, Mehitable and Jerathmiel call upon the heavenly choir of the Nine Principalities to give them victory over the witches, causing the Weird Sisters to bleed from their eyes and ears. Mehitable and Jerathmiel tell them that they are no ordinary witch-hunters as they are angels.
Dorcas is tied to a pole
The Weird Sisters, along with the rest of the coven, are taken captive by the witch-hunters and locked up in the Desecrated Church. Dorcas, Agatha, and Prudence are tied up and are to be burned at the stake. He tells them that God will forgive their sins if they vow to accept Him as their Savior. He adds that their bodies will be consumed and purified by the fire of righteousness. When Elspeth refuses to denounce the Dark Lord, Jerathmiel slits her throat. Sabrina arrives and he shoots her down with arrows. Presumably killing her. Dorcas, Agatha, and Prudence are distraught. He then turns his attention to Melvin and kills him. Jerathmiel is about to burn the Weird Sisters when Sabrina suddenly awakens and starts to levitate. She demands that the witch-hunters convert to Lucifer's faith. Sabrina summons fire with her hands and forces Jerathmiel and Mehitable to their knees. After Jerathmiel and Mehitable have uttered the prayer, Sabrina burns them alive.[6]
The Execution of Ambrose Spellman[]
Following the destruction of the angelic witch-hunters, the witches return to the Academy. Sabrina awakens, pulls the arrow out her chest, and miraculously heals Ambrose.
The Weird Sisters mock Sabrina
The Weird Sisters enter the cafeteria and mock Sabrina as she preaches her father's teachings and philosophies. Prudence says that mortals hate and fear witches and is astounded that Sabrina expects witches to be with them. Sabrina counters that her father married a mortal. Prudence disagrees. Knowing that she is unable to convince Prudence and the Weird Sisters with her words, Sabrina uses her powers to cause rose petals to fall. Prudence is frightened and asks Sabrina how she is doing this.
Dorcas and Agatha at the execution
The following day at the Desecrated Church, the Church of Night have gathered for the execution of Ambrose. The Weird Sisters are in attendance. Due to the lack of new evidence, Methuselah orders that Ambrose's execution to proceed as planned. The Infernal Bailiff drags Ambrose before the guillotine and places his head in the block. The executioner lowers the blade but is instead beheaded by a killing spell. Before long, the Dark Lord appears. Lucifer chastises him for degrading the coven with his pettiness and orders Ambrose spared before disappearing. Methuselah declares that Ambrose is reprieved and orders his release.
Dorcas and Agatha later attend a party for witches and mortals at Sabrina's house, where she intends to show the mortals what she is capable of but decides against it at the last moment.[7]
The Weird Sisters listen as Father Blackwood lists the new tenants
Father Blackwood addresses the Academy of Unseen Arts regarding the Witches' Council turning its back on them. Father Blackwood is willing to shield them and to guide them back to the old ways. The Judas Society unveils a statue of himself and renames the Church of Night to the "Church of Judas." He commands them to look to the Five Facets of Judas for salvation and exaltation.[8]
Killing Father Blackwood[]
The Weird sisters try to kill Father Blackwood
Prudence approaches Dorcas and Agatha for their help. They reject being called sisters, seeing as they don't share the Blackwood name. When Prudence reveals to them of her plan to kill Faustus Blackwood, she gains their attention. How they will do it since he won’t let them get close, they ask. Prudence replies that they won't need to and shows a red ribbon. The Weird Sisters sing and dance around a statue of Father Blackwood while holding the red cloth in a triangle. Blackwood leaves his office and finds the Weird Sisters in the lobby. He tells Prudence that the Dark Lord has summoned him and that she must attend.
Agatha, Dorcas, Melvin, and Elspeth prepare to drink
The coven gathers at the Desecrated Church. Father Blackwood gives an embellished account of his meeting with the Dark Lord and claims that the Dark Lord proclaimed his Church of Judas as the one true Churches of Darkness. The coven hails Satan and take part in an Unholy Communion. The witches and warlocks step forward to drink the wine. Agatha and Dorcas reluctantly obey orders to step forward as Blackwood shouts "Hail Satan."
Prudence finds her Sisters poisoned
Prudence arrives at the Desecrated Church to find Dorcas and Agatha choking on poison. As it turns out, after being reprimanded by the Dark Lord, Father Blackwood had plans to kill the coven and leave town. Prudence teleports herself and her sisters to the Spellman household. Prudence begs Zelda, Hilda, and Ambrose to help and reveals that Blackwood poisoned the entire coven. She tells Zelda that they are still alive and are at the Desecrated Church. While Hilda and Prudence attend to the Weird Sisters, Zelda and Ambrose teleport themselves to the Desecrated Church.[9]