I know. They spent season 2 making it look supernatural and went away from it in the finale.
Season 1 was still my favorite. I really enjoyed Season 2 until they failed to have a Sabrina crossover and went away from the supernatural elements.
Love the Simpson House of Horrors idea. Fantastic
I'd have had more of the supporting characters of RIVERDALE appear on CAOS. Probably not the main 4 of Archie/Veronica/JugHead/Betty but having Sabrina go to Pop's store and have her order taken by Pop, or having her interact with Cheryl would have been something.
Because there was no way of knowing that Luke Perry was going to have the stroke and then pass away the way he so tragically did, I personally would have considered bringing in Jason Priestly in recasting the role. I think the fan's would have accepted that recasting of the role with Jason in the role of someone he worked with in BH 90210.
It seemed to Archie that Betty was 'the girl next door' and saw her in a sisterly way I think.