Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-4723271-20171211184327/@comment-1186-20171212063701

I do think a category should include ANY past or present member of that group, but I can live with omitting ones who predate the series (I don't think anyone wants to include all the parents in the "Riverdale High Students" category, for example). There's not likely to be many other instances of that anyway.

So can we say there's a consensus?