Talk:Chapter Thirty-Nine: The Midnight Club/@comment-37186493-20181026225542

After looking at the promo photos, I think Madelaine Petsch might be playing both Mary Andrews and Penelope Blossom.

Current Penelope almost always wears her hair in a low bun, expensive clothes, and gloves (even prior to her burns. Ref: Penelope at Polly's baby shower). The photo with Trevor as young Clifford, Madelaine is wearing her hair in a low bun with a full blazer and dark gloves. Current Mary Andrews has relatively short hair, but typically wears it down, and Madelaine is mostly seen in promotional photos with her hair in a braid and more age appropriate clothes.

Also, note the different glasses. Madelaine with Trevor has light/nude rimmed glasses that frame just her eyes, while Madeline in the other photos has dark rimmed glasses that are so big, they go from the bottom of her eyebrow to the tip of her nose.