Board Thread:Theories/@comment-26600747-20180510022214/@comment-26600747-20180510131152

That is all very possible but I reallllly don't want it to be a twin. Would they really copy PLL like that? Right down to the twin appearing in scenes when we think it is the person we know. I would hate that.

But it would answer some questions.

I do think Charles is Hal's son and inherited the darkness, whether he is working with Hal or his twin. Alice reminding Hal (and us) that she "stepped out on him with FP" means she was sleeping with both of them at the same time and could have just thought FP was the dad, especially after Chic's DNA test.