Board Thread:Theories/@comment-32372311-20171128211559/@comment-4723271-20171201192345

While I don't believe that Penny is related to Alice, saying that "Betty would know if she had an aunt" isn't necessarily true. Betty didn't even know that Alice was from the Southside. And if Betty's never met her grandparents (Alice's parents), then its completely believable that she wouldn't know that she had an aunt.