Board Thread:Theories/@comment-26849089-20180510221020/@comment-26600747-20180511134947

there are a few theories being floated in the other threads. The one that seems to make the most sense is that the real BH took advantage of Hal's troubled childhood (just as he did with Svenson) and blackmailed him into going after Cheryl and confessing to his family.

So who is the real BH? My theory is that Charles is not dead, and is actually Hal's son. They made a point of having Alice say she "stepped out on him with FP" so she was sleeping with them at the same time and might have just assumed FP was the dad, especially after Chic's DNA test. They also made the point that the "darkness" is passed down from father to son.