Board Thread:Theories/@comment-13895380-20171112172827/@comment-60.241.46.97-20171208215740

Also explains the arguement that FP saw between Hal and Alice when they were young. Perhaps it was about the real father of the child.

AlphaOfAlphas wrote:

Killer kev wrote: Green eyes are reason to speculate that the Black Hood is her father? Seems trivial, at best, especially considering how common they are. Hal is her biological father as far as we know. I think its far more likely that her long-lost brother is the Black Hood Really? All you got out of my post was that they both have green eyes? lol Seems like there is more evidence that it's her father than brother tbh, unless they gave more info last episode (haven't watched it yet).

Betty can inherit green eyes from her father but not her brother (obviously). She can inherit her darker nature from a parent, not a sibling. Black hood doesn't care about Polly, but cares about Betty. If Black Hood was Betty's brother, he'd share the same sibling bond with Polly too but he clearly doesn't. If he's her father, however, it'll explain why he is bonded to Betty but not Polly, as the latter is not his child at all. We also know Alice used to be a Serpent, in the southside, so maybe that's when she met Betty's father, then abandoned him later on. We also know that she tries to cover up her family flaws so the Coopers will always appear as perfect, so I wouldn't put it past her to lie to the "father" and keep the secret that Betty isn't his child for all these years. The Black Hood wants to expose Riverdale for its hypocrisy, and Alice is the queen of hypocrisy. They also did the "sibling missing" story with Polly so I don't they'd do it again with a long-lost brother.

Yeah, so I'm going with biological father. If not, I hope it's a non-sibling character.